Death and taxes: Germany’s Inheritance and Gift Tax Act goes back to court

Wednesday 18 November 2026

Few tax laws have come before Germany’s Federal Constitutional Court as often as the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (‘ErbStG’), which was the subject of another oral hearing on 12 and 13 October 2026. Its constitutionality has come under scrutiny for the fourth time since 1995, once again raising questions about the generous tax exemption for business assets that plays a crucial role in succession planning for wealthy families.

The saga began in 1995. At that time, the Federal Constitutional Court objected to the fact that real estate with outdated tax values, some of which were decades old, was valued significantly lower than capital assets. The next objection followed in 2006: a uniform tax rate could not be applied to assets valued using fundamentally different methods depending on the type of asset. In the 2009 reform, the legislature then uniformly focused on the market value – and at the same time introduced a tax exemption of 85 per cent or 100 per cent for business assets.

It was precisely this exemption that led to the law being struck down again five years later. In its judgment of 17 December 2014,[1] the Federal Constitutional Court acknowledged the legislature may give preferential treatment to business assets in order to preserve family businesses and jobs. However, the specific provisions were found to be disproportionate in certain respects. These included the exemption for large businesses without assessing whether the recipient was genuinely unable to pay the tax; the exemption of businesses with up to 20 employees from the requirement to preserve jobs; and the preferential treatment of businesses whose assets comprised up to 50 per cent non-operating assets, such as rental properties or securities. The legislature failed to meet the 30 June 2016 deadline for introducing new legislation. Because the two legislative chambers, the Bundestag and the Bundesrat, were initially unable to reach an agreement, the reform was not passed until autumn 2016 and was applied retroactively from 1 July 2016. At the heart of the revised rules is a threshold of €26m per acquisition. Above this threshold, the exemption is gradually reduced, or the tax is waived on application to the extent that the recipient cannot pay it from half of their remaining private assets.[2]

It is precisely this concept that the current proceedings[3] are directed against. Unlike in 2006 and 2014, the case was not referred to the Federal Constitutional Court by Germany’s highest tax court, the Federal Tax Court. Instead, the challenge was brought by an heir who inherited only private assets – a securities portfolio and real estate – from his aunt and paid around €47,000 in inheritance tax. He sees himself disadvantaged because heirs of business assets in a comparable situation can remain largely or completely exempt from tax. The Court focused its review on the principle of equality under the German constitution, comparing recipients of privileged and non-privileged assets.

The figures presented in the hearing illustrate the scale of the issue: in 2025 alone, tax exemptions for business assets amounted to over €21bn. A further €13bn was waived under the needs test. Overall, about three-quarters of the transferred eligible business assets remained tax-exempt; in previous years the proportion was in some cases significantly higher. At the centre of the legal debate was section 28a of ErbStG. Critics argued that the provision allows inheritance and gift tax to be waived almost entirely on very large transfers, bases relief on the recipient’s ability to pay rather than the risk to the business and can be exploited through tax planning arrangements such as family foundations or the use of heirs with no assets of their own. The German government defended the provision as complying with the requirements laid down in 2014, pointing to the broad discretion afforded to the legislature under Germany’s Constitution.

The day before, the Court had heard an application by the state of Bavaria.[4] Bavaria considers it unconstitutional that tax allowances, tax rates and property valuation are uniformly regulated nationwide. It would like to regulate these issues itself in the future, criticising the fact that the personal allowances have not been adjusted for inflation since 2009. The Court reacted rather skeptically.

The Court gave no clear indication of its likely direction in either case. However, many observers assume that improvements will have to be made – if at all – especially in the treatment of acquisitions above €26m, while the basic concept of an exemption for business assets could be maintained. A judgment is expected in a few months. In 2014, about five months passed between the hearing and the judgment. The Court’s ruling will coincide with an already charged political debate. In early 2026, the governing Social Democrats (SPD) proposed reforms introducing a lifetime tax-free allowance and a separate allowance for business assets, drawing strong opposition from their senior coalition partner, the Christian Democrat (CDU/CSU) bloc. A ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court could resolve this.

At its core, the message is simple: the constitutionality of Germany’s inheritance tax regime has remained unresolved for three decades, with each ruling by the Federal Constitutional Court so far prompting fundamental reform. For clients abroad, this is relevant even if they do not live in Germany themselves. This is because German inheritance tax covers the entire worldwide acquisition if only one party, the deceased or donor or recipient, is resident in Germany. In the case of German nationals, this applies even for a five-year period after they have moved abroad. However, even if none of the parties is resident in Germany, the acquisition does not automatically remain tax-exempt. Under the system of limited tax liability, Germany taxes domestic assets, in particular real estate located in Germany, assets of a German permanent establishment and shareholdings of at least ten per cent in German corporations. Particularly in the case of such shareholdings, the tax burden for purchasers abroad therefore also depends directly on whether the exemption rules survive. The existing law remains in force until the Court delivers its ruling. Anyone planning to transfer German company shareholdings, especially larger assets, should nevertheless review their plans now. This is because back in 2014, the Federal Constitutional Court expressly allowed the legislature to extend a new provision retroactively to the day of the pronouncement of the judgment in order to prevent excessive exploitation of the previous legal situation.


[1] Judgment of 17 December 2014 (1 BvL 21/12).

[2] Needs test, ErbStG s 28a.

[3] 1 BvR 804/22.

[4] 1 BvF 1/23.