Nobel Peace Prize highlights importance of international justice system
In October, the Nobel Peace Prize for 2026 was awarded to Navanethem ‘Navi’ Pillay. The choice of Pillay – who has been an International Criminal Court judge among her numerous roles – as this year’s recipient comes as the international justice system faces sustained attack. In a statement, the Norwegian Nobel Committee said that through this year’s Nobel Peace Prize, it ‘wants to remind the world that the rule of law – national and international – underpins the system we have set up to ensure peace and resolve conflicts non-violently. Peace requires justice.’
Just hours after the Prize was awarded to Pillay, the Trump administration announced sweeping sanctions on the ICC. Days earlier, US President Donald Trump had said that it would be a ‘great discredit’ to the Nobel Committee if he wasn’t awarded the prize. The administration has previously imposed sanctions on ICC judges and staff. Its latest action targets the Court itself as an institution. ‘We will ban transactions with this rogue court, cutting off their resources and crippling its ability to operate,’ said US Secretary of State, Marco Rubio. The State Department has claimed that ‘the ICC poses an intolerable threat to US sovereignty – it claims the authority to prosecute and even imprison American servicemen and officials operating on behalf of America’s national interest.’
The ICC describes the sanctions as ‘an attempt to obstruct the course of justice and to prevent the Court from doing what it was created to do’ and further as ‘an assault on the rule of law and on the very foundations of the international legal order which strikes at the simple principle that no one stands above the law.’
‘The sanctions attack the very principles of international justice that Navi Pillay’s Nobel Peace Prize celebrates,’ says Jonathan Hafetz, an officer of the IBA Human Rights Law Committee and a professor of law at Seton Hall Law School in New Jersey. ‘They transform a tool with the potential to combat human rights abuses into a weapon to be wielded against those seeking accountability, shielding powerful states and their allies while punishing those who investigate their alleged crimes.’
These efforts that we are now seeing, which are attempts to weaken international criminal justice, endanger the progress painstakingly made since the Nuremberg Trials
Navi Pillay
Recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize for 2026
Asked whether the award is a response to attacks on international courts, Jørgen Watne Frydnes, Chair of the Norwegian Nobel Committee, reportedly said that ‘this is definitely a message to those who are attacking, undermining the international system, the international rules-based system, and the institutions.’
Pillay discovered she’d won the award while sitting in Courtroom 600 of the Nuremberg Palace of Justice – where Nazi leaders were placed on trial following the Second World War, and where key principles of today’s system of international justice were established. Pillay said it was perhaps ‘meant to be’ that the Courtroom is where she found herself when the announcement was made. ‘These efforts that we are now seeing, which are attempts to weaken international criminal justice, endanger the progress painstakingly made since Nuremberg, and they risk returning us to a world in which power rather than law determines whose suffering matters,’ said Pillay.
Pillay has had a long career in international justice. She defended Nelson Mandela in South Africa, where she became a judge on the High Court. Mandela later appointed her as a judge at the International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda. Pillay also served as the UN Commissioner for Human Rights from 2008−2014. She currently sits as a judge on the International Court of Justice, which recently heard the case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar, in which the latter is accused of genocide against the Rohingya minority, an allegation the country’s leadership denies.
In 2025, Pillay chaired the UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, which said that Israel has committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. Israel, which rejected the UN Commission’s report and called it ‘false’, denounced the Nobel Committee for awarding the Peace Prize to Pillay.
Pillay’s dedication to the rule of law and her service as a judge on national and international courts make her an ‘extraordinary and exceptional human who received the prize at this moment in time, when threats have been levied at international courts and international judges, not just by the United States but by the Russian Federation,’ says Leila Sadat, a former Member of the IBA War Crimes Committee Advisory Board and the James Carr Professor of International Criminal Law at the Washington University Law School in St Louis.
In December 2025, Russia convicted eight ICC judges in absentia on charges related to the ‘unlawful prosecution of Russian citizens’, after the Court issued arrest warrants for President Vladimir Putin and the country’s Children’s Rights Commissioner Maria Lvova-Belova in 2023. The pair are accused of the illegal deportation of children from the occupied Ukrainian territories to Russia, which they deny. In February, a group of UN human rights experts called Russia’s convictions of the ICC judges ‘legally null and void under international law’.
Pillay’s win ‘is a tribute to the need for justice and accountability and their critical role in the maintenance for international peace and security,’ says Sadat, who served as Special Adviser on Crimes Against Humanity to two ICC prosecutors and is the Director of the Crimes Against Humanity Initiative.
ICC President Tomoko Akane, herself under US sanctions, said that the prize being awarded to Pillay ‘is an important recognition of the vital role that international justice plays as a cornerstone of lasting peace’. Daniela Gavshon, Co-Chair of the IBA War Crimes Committee, says that ‘we are living in a time when international justice is under threat which makes it even more meaningful that someone like Navi Pillay has been recognised for the influence she has had on global human rights and the international justice system.’
Sadat is hopeful that the results of the recent US midterm elections – which saw control of the country’s legislature taken away from President Trump’s party – will mark the beginning of a changing relationship with the ICC. ‘I am hopeful that with the recent elections in the US we can mount an educational and political campaign to finally get the United States behind the ICC and understand how much this court and what it stands for means to the international community and to the global rule of law,’ she says.
Header image: J-L Flémal - BE - stock.adobe.com